Why Multitasking Makes You Smarter

Have you ever felt guilty about checking your email while on a conference call, or switching between three different projects in a single afternoon? You've probably heard the research: multitasking kills productivity, destroys focus, and turns your brain into mush.

But what if that's only half the story?

Picture this: You're working on a design project when a colleague pings you about a budget question. While answering, you notice a connection between the budget constraint and your design problem. You switch back, now seeing your original project from a completely new angle. That "distraction" just solved a problem you'd been stuck on for hours.

Was that multitasking? Absolutely. Did it make you less effective? Not even close.

The Research They Don't Tell You About

Here's what every productivity guru loves to cite: A 2009 Stanford study showed that heavy multitaskers performed worse on cognitive tests than people who focus on one thing at a time. Case closed, right?

Not quite. What they don't mention is what happened next.

Researcher David Strayer at the University of Utah discovered something unexpected: about 2.5% of people are what he calls "supertaskers"—individuals who actually perform better when juggling multiple activities. But here's the more interesting part: these aren't genetic freaks with different brains. They're people who've trained their cognitive flexibility through years of context-switching.

Think of it like this: If you only ever lift weights with your right arm, your left arm stays weak. If you only ever focus on one task at a time, your brain's task-switching muscles atrophy.

The Surgeon Who Plays Jazz

Dr. Michael Mosely is a neurosurgeon. He's also a jazz pianist. During a typical surgery, he's monitoring patient vitals, coordinating with nurses, making split-second decisions, and maintaining steady hands—all simultaneously.

When researchers studied surgeons like Mosely, they expected to find that the best ones had exceptional single-task focus. Instead, they found the opposite: elite surgeons excel at distributed attention. They're constantly monitoring multiple information streams and integrating them in real-time.

"Surgery isn't about focusing on one thing," Mosely explains. "It's about maintaining awareness of everything while acting on the right thing at the right moment. That's not focus—that's orchestrated chaos."

His jazz training? It turns out that improvisational music requires exactly the same cognitive skill set: tracking multiple instruments, anticipating changes, responding in real-time, all while creating something new.

The multitasking trained him for surgery. The surgery made him better at jazz.

Your Brain's Operating System

Neuroscientist Earl Miller discovered something fascinating about how our brains actually work: We don't really multitask—we rapidly switch between tasks. But here's the counterintuitive part: that switching itself is a trainable cognitive skill.

Think of your brain like a computer's operating system. When you only run one program at a time, your system never learns to manage resources efficiently. But when you regularly switch between programs, your OS gets better at allocation, faster at context-switching, and more efficient at memory management.

Miller's research showed that people who regularly engage in task-switching actually develop stronger executive function—the cognitive control system that manages attention, working memory, and flexible thinking.

Related Reading: Sometimes, instead of switching, we need to stop entirely. Discover why your most creative breakthroughs happen during 'wasted' time.

In other words, controlled multitasking doesn't just make you better at multitasking. It makes you better at thinking.

The Billionaire's Calendar

Look at how Richard Branson structures his day. He's not blocking out four-hour deep work sessions. He's typically juggling conversations about Virgin Airlines, Virgin Galactic, and three other ventures—often in the same hour.

"People tell me I should focus on one company," Branson once said. "But the cross-pollination between businesses is where the magic happens. A problem in one area often contains the solution to a problem somewhere else."

This isn't scattered thinking—it's integrative thinking. The ability to hold multiple contexts in mind simultaneously and find unexpected connections between them.

Steve Jobs did something similar. Apple engineers reported that he'd often interrupt focused work sessions to ask about completely unrelated projects. Annoying? Definitely. But it forced the team to think about how disparate elements could connect—leading to innovations like using iPod technology in iPhones.

The Context-Switching Advantage

Here's what the anti-multitasking crowd gets wrong: they assume all tasks are created equal and all switching is bad. But research by Sophie Leroy at the University of Minnesota reveals something more nuanced.

When you're stuck on a difficult problem, switching to a different task—especially an easier one—allows your unconscious mind to continue processing the hard problem. Leroy calls this "cognitive offloading." You're not abandoning the difficult task; you're giving your brain permission to solve it in the background.

Professional writers have known this for decades. Stuck on a scene? Switch to editing an earlier chapter. Many writers report that the solution to their stuck scene often arrives while they're working on something completely different.

Ernest Hemingway famously stopped writing mid-sentence each day, then spent the rest of his afternoon fishing or drinking. Was he being lazy? No—he was letting his subconscious finish the sentence while his conscious mind did something else.

The Monotasking Trap

Here's the uncomfortable truth: the modern push for single-tasking might be training people for a world that no longer exists.

In the 20th century, most knowledge work involved completing discrete, sequential tasks. You'd write a report, then move to the next report. Deep focus made sense.

But 21st-century knowledge work looks different. You're simultaneously managing projects, responding to real-time communication, monitoring changing conditions, and integrating information from multiple sources. The person who can only do one thing at a time isn't more focused—they're less adaptive.

Researchers at the University of Michigan found that professionals who regularly practice task-switching show greater cognitive flexibility, better problem-solving across domains, and higher capacity for innovation.

The monotaskers? They got really good at doing one type of task. But when conditions changed, they struggled to adapt.

The Multitasking Spectrum

Before you start juggling chainsaws during your next Zoom call, let's be clear: there's smart multitasking and stupid multitasking.

Stupid multitasking: Texting while driving. Writing important emails during critical meetings. Trying to do two cognitively demanding tasks that require the same mental resources.

Smart multitasking: Switching between complementary tasks. Pairing high-focus work with routine tasks. Using "productive procrastination" to let problems marinate while working on something else.

The key is understanding cognitive load. Your brain has different types of processing capacity. When you pair tasks that use different cognitive resources—say, listening to instrumental music while writing, or walking while brainstorming—you're not actually competing for the same mental bandwidth.

The Two-Minute Rule Reimagined

David Allen's "Getting Things Done" methodology suggests: if something takes less than two minutes, do it immediately. Most people interpret this as a way to clear small tasks.

But there's a hidden benefit: these micro-task switches keep your brain nimble. When you shift quickly between a two-minute email response and your main project, you're training your brain's context-switching capability.

Professional athletes do something similar. Between sets, they don't just rest—they visualize different aspects of their sport, check stats, or mentally rehearse other techniques. This constant shifting keeps their minds sharp and responsive.

The Integration Skill

What separates effective multitaskers from scattered ones? Integration ability—the capacity to see how different activities relate to each other.

Poor multitaskers see three separate tasks. Skilled multitaskers see three facets of a larger puzzle.

Take Leonardo da Vinci. His notebooks jump chaotically between anatomy sketches, engineering designs, artistic techniques, and philosophical musings—often on the same page. Scattered ADHD? Or was he recognizing patterns that connected art, science, and engineering?

His ability to switch between domains didn't dilute his genius—it defined it. The anatomical knowledge informed his art. The artistic training shaped his engineering. The engineering refined his scientific observation.

What This Means for Monday Morning

Should you abandon single-tasking entirely? Of course not. Deep focus has its place. But maybe it's time to stop treating task-switching like a character flaw and start treating it like a cognitive skill worth developing.

Try this experiment: Next time you're stuck on a problem, deliberately switch to a different project for 20 minutes. Not mindless scrolling—actual work on something else. Notice if the solution to your original problem emerges while you're working on the second thing.

Or try "structured multitasking": dedicate specific time blocks to rapidly rotating between related projects. You might discover that the cross-pollination generates insights that pure focus never would.

The goal isn't to become scattered. It's to become cognitively flexible—able to focus deeply when needed and switch rapidly when advantageous.

Your productivity guru friends might think you're losing focus. But while they're optimizing for depth in a single domain, you're training your brain to see connections they'll miss entirely.

The question isn't whether you should multitask. It's whether you can afford not to develop the cognitive flexibility that modern work demands.

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Is multitasking really better for your brain?

It’s not that multitasking is inherently "better," but rather that controlled task-switching builds cognitive flexibility. Most traditional productivity advice focuses on single-tasking (monotasking), but research shows that the ability to rapidly shift focus is a critical skill for 21st-century knowledge work.

What is a "supertasker"?

Supertaskers are individuals (estimated to be about 2.5% of the population) who actually perform better, not worse, when juggling multiple cognitively demanding tasks. However, even if you aren't a "natural" supertasker, you can train your brain's context-switching capability through practice.

Does this mean I should check my phone while working?

No. That is "stupid multitasking"—pairing two high-focus tasks that compete for the same mental resources. "Smart multitasking" involves pairing complementary tasks or using task-switching as a way to jumpstart a stuck brain by letting ideas "cross-pollinate" between different projects.

How do I avoid "attention residue"?

Attention residue is the mental fog that occurs when you switch from one task to another but part of your brain is still stuck on the first one. To minimize this, use "clean breaks"—brief, intentional transitions between tasks where you physically shift your environment or take a deep breath to reset your focus.